The worst "reproduction" panel I've ever seen, and I saw a lot of 'em, was Sherman & Associates' mid-1990s quarter patch for, according to them, 1971-'74 Charger (never mind that there were three different panels in those four years). Body lines that didn't exist, others that crossed each other, all the while having no contour to it whatsoever, much less anywhere near the right outside dimensions. It made that floorpan look like NOS Chrysler; I joked that we'd need to expand the old YOCLASS system to at least 8 for that one. EFI Ed joked that it looked like one of those cheap tin backyard sheds got tossed against a '73 Charger by a tornado. Sherman wanted
$250 for it, plus truck freight, in 1996 dollars. :doh:
For a scosche over $100 shipped for the pair, those really aren't
that terrible. They're something from which you can work, anyhow.
A pair of full-length '67-'76 pans from AMD will set you back nearly five bills with the shipping, and Auto Body Specialties wants $479 plus shipping for four
patches for the '62-'66 A-bodies. The
A.B.S. pans are still sorta shabby-looking; it doesn't look like whomever stamped them has quite nailed the process. They're much better than what you've got there, and the price reflects it. They're also really the only option available as far as I know.
I've worked with more reproduction sheetmetal already than I'd ever planned, and I'll be working with more before I'm done. I'm not claiming to be anywhere near a Restoman-level expert, but I can say the AMD pans I bought for the Valiant were noticeably better than the Goodmark deck-filler panel and quarter panel (from both of which I only used pieces, but regardless) and the Golden Star (?) roof for the Challenger. The adage about getting what you paid for applies. Both cars suffered considerable hits to the same area (RH front) but I had the Challenger put on a frame rack to straighten it; the Valiant got no such luxury. The AMD panels still fit better; I suspect they'd be almost perfect if the car wasn't bent--and make no mistake, she's bent. It's worth mentioning that no reproduction panel I've yet seen is the same gauge as original. If OE was 14, repro will be approximately 16. 16 OE means ~18 repro, and so on. I don't think the Asian factories are using straight-up US Standard gauging for their sheetmetal, so it's not a straight variance.