Looking for garage/shop info....

thrashingcows

Drowning deep in my sea of loathing...so I'm
Since moving up north and to our new place on acreage...with no shop :( ...I am looking to build a shop this coming year. Just brain storming and wonder about putting a hoist in the shop. Now people who have done this, or are privy to this info, how tall a ceiling do you need, and any other pertinent info?

I have a blank slate and want to make this the best I can....within a reasonable budget of course. Thinking of a shop around 40' x 40' or so. So any thoughts, suggestions and comments about your current shop/garage, and the size, shape and configuration and construction materials would also be appreciated.

All comments, suggestions, and ideas are appreciated.
 
I would sugest at least a 12' ceiling for your needs. I have a 4 post hoist in my garage with a 10' ceiling. With the Duster on the hoist and close to the ceiling it is about right for me underneath, but I am 5'7". You would not be comfortable under mine.
 
I would suggest at least 12' ceilings with another 2-3' if you can manage it. I'd also leave enough room for attic crawl space storage, with a good access point. I learned that with my uncle's garage, 32X60 with 18' ceiling, almost no upper storage, and now that he's in his 60's it's a PITA for him to get anything up or down from there.
 
its not the ceiling height that matters right off the bat.....


its the LIFT and what you want to put on it most lift have the "over the top" cable arangement, and being the big guy you are and the fact you have a truck, id be either looking for a tall lift, one made for trucks/vans, or a lift that can have "extensions" put at the top to allow for more height when tossing a big toy on it...i say this specificly as you have a truck, and your over 6ft tall....at that point the LIFT still is your ceiling height dictator

now if you get an open top lift of some kind everything changes

these things said 12-15ft is the "norm" on most "pole barn" orders....and at 15 ft, you put a truck on a open lift and max it out you will likely be neer touching the rafters.....cars are another story entirely having had 15ft(it shrunk to about 13.5 after concreete) i can tell you that you stick a truck on a closed top lift get yourself a good stool that rolls cause you will NOT be standing under the truck..EVER keep one thing in mind when building a shop, going "taller" after its built is possible but will cost you considerably more....

from what i remember the foundation is the expensive part, get yourself fiber reinforced so it never cracks, and "zip strip" type seams so a car on wheel dolleys rolls effortlessly, plan out where you want the lift, and pour a deep footing for it so it takes ALL of the stress off the main floor if it were me, i would plan for the biggest tallest lift i could find and then give it its own bay door with plenty of work around room..i would NOT stick it in the middle of the shop again so that its perminantly in the way taking up the most space possible , another thought would be a moveable 4post stacker type with slide jacks similar to an alignment rack

2 post is a PAIN when your working and need to open doors etc
4 post can be a pain with axle stuff "platform" type seem to have the least amount of drawbacks. while an axle cant come directly out the down, you get a nice "platform" to set it on, and your lift points are fully adjustable, and a transmission jack can be added
scissor lifts are invaluable tho, from body work to suspension, portable, take up neer zero shop space, double as an adjustable height welding table, bike table, quads, lawn equipment etc, the only drawback ive found so far is NO transmission or exhaust work, heck ive figured out how to "adjust" and move mine WITH a car on it(not far but fore/aft in small incerments)

these points noted, i personaly would be on the hunt for a high end/ex shop pieces, either a 10k+ 4post, or a 10k+ platform, and a 8k+ scissor, and just skip the 2 post, 4 posts are sooo much more stable and dont get "bouncy" when your working on that nut that wont bust free and wont get sketchy when you drop the front end assembly like a 2post can, and while someone will likely mention the space a 4post takes up, technicality i say since a 2post takes up the same footprint with a toy loaded onto it, its only the unloaded size that changes

after working with the 30x60 i could toss improvements at you all day long, from mistakes that were made, to improvements id wish id had, to things i learned and would never do again...if you want ill toss more in as i think of it

being your further north now, PLAN for heating right up front, and while you can probably supliment a wood stove, i wouldnt count on it doing the startup job, go gas heating for the initial take the chill out and then fire up the wood stove, put the gas on a engage on the HOUSE side so you can go out to a pre warmed shop while getting breakfast, but honestly a wood stove in a shop does not heat well once you get over the size of a 2car garage
 
Last edited:
I didn't even consider a moveable 4 post. I'd go that route, with roller jacks on it, they're tough to do exhaust work on, but if it has the roller plates they make eyeball alignments a breeze. You can store 2 cars out of the way, during your long miserable winter, and still have room for Patches and your skid steer inside.
 
Thanks for the thoughts. I had been considering the 4 post style though....2 post with the size, weight and length of Ol'patches would seem a bit sketchy. The heating wired to the house is a great idea! The efficiency of the wood burner stove is interesting....will have to look into it. Many have suggested putting in heated flooring piping, even if I don't get to hook it up right away.

And please give me any building thoughts, lessons learned, improvements and regrets.
 
Infloor heating with an outdoor wood/gas boiler would be the way to go. No open flame in the shop to accidently ignite any gas vapours.
 
Pretty much everything 69.5 mentioned is the way I would be looking at things. Especially setting the lift off to one side... no matter how big you build the garage, it'll never be big enough and a hoist planted in the middle of the floor makes it seem even smaller.
In floor heating is the BOMB!
If your building codes allow it, put down some foam board insulation before pouring out the concrete.
 
As far as lifts go...

I'm 6'6", and I worked fifty or more hours a week for years under a two post asymmetrical lift that wasn't tall enough for me to stand under, and loved it. I got a crappy desk chair with a half broken back piece and sat under it to work, rolled everywhere.. It was a slight inconvenience at the middle, because the chains ran under a plate that was about 1.5 inches off of the ground. Only one time out of ten did I need the height of a better lift, and that was when I was muscling transmissions in or out of cars. I've also worked on four posters, and hated every minute of it. Most of what you (I) do to the lower part of a vehicle is wheel/suspension/brake based. After you drive the car on the lift, and lift it.. you still have to lift the car to get the weight off of the wheel so you can take it off. After that, any time you're wailing on something, or pulling hard on a breaker bar, your chest is in the ramp, your arms only have half their range of motion (and leverage), and if you slip, you bust your hands and your funnybone. I get that your truck is huge, and two post lifts are a little under qualified for it. My truck doesn't play well with them either.. but the beauty of doing work to the underside of a big truck is that you usually don't need a jack, just roll under it. I really wish I had a nice shop and a butch lift when I pulled the NP435 and transfer case in and out of that thing twice, though.. But how often do any of us normally have to pull transmissions out of our personal cars? I'll be totally honest here, 80% of the time I put a car on my little scissors lift at home, it's to bring the engine bay up to a working height so I don't have to bend over. I do really like my scissors lift, but that might be stockholm's syndrome talking because my ceiling is 8 foot, and I pretty much had to get that style.. They do make an electric screw style lift that never gets any taller as it raises, and I was about to buy one of those, but lost my nerve at the end because I wasn't quite sure if my ceiling was tall enough, or my old concrete pad thick enough.

You can get almost any style of lift used for $1000-$1500 if you're patient. You can also find any style of lift for $2000-$3000 if you're not. If it were my money, as well as my building I was designing from scratch, I'd spend $2000-$3000 total, get one of each, and just kill an extra 200 square feet from the start. You won't miss it if you never had it. Or get a big ass one for your truck, and redhead it to the concrete, and get a scissors lift like mine and move it around for light duty stuff.

Don't forget a sink, and a shitter in the corner.. Trust me, it's no fun having to clean up to go inside your nice house to make a fudgie.. Keeps the black fingerprints off the white door jambs as well. Your wife will thank me.
 
Last edited:
Infloor heating with an outdoor wood/gas boiler would be the way to go. No open flame in the shop to accidently ignite any gas vapours.

Been thinking about that very thing. Very popular up north where I live. One of my co-workers has one that heats his house, and the huge 60x60 shop.....I should go over to his place and check out the system.

Pretty much everything 69.5 mentioned is the way I would be looking at things. Especially setting the lift off to one side... no matter how big you build the garage, it'll never be big enough and a hoist planted in the middle of the floor makes it seem even smaller.
In floor heating is the BOMB!
If your building codes allow it, put down some foam board insulation before pouring out the concrete.

Will put the foam board insulation on the list of things to check with the building inspectors.

Ironsausage.....great advice.....will think hard on everything you mentioned.
 
Also, don't waste any space on creature comforts besides the sink, shitter, decent stereo, car art on the walls, and basic climate control.. The second you put a comfortable chair, couch, or screen of any kind in there, nothing will get done.. Man caves are for 1970's basements with a bar, Irish paneling, and a neon Genesee sign behind it, they're a good place to drink with friends, not to get work done..
 
Not really planning on "man cave" amenities.....but an old sofa might make it in there for naps. ;)
 
One of my co-workers has one that heats his house, and the huge 60x60 shop.....I should go over to his place and check out the system.

My brother uses the same system for his house & 40' X 60' shed. Keep in mind the time & investment gathering wood. Also, if you do, get the largest firepot you can afford, so you don't have to stoke it so often. you can turn the temp down when not needed. But the biggest drawback is the recovery time. It takes a lot longer to heat cement than air. Using the outdoor wood is fantastic when used for a house & shop combo. But for a shop only that's not used daily it can be a lot of extra hassle. Having a shitter & sink would be nice but you need to add huge work & $$$ to run plumbing and to your septic. Then you MUST keep it heated 24 -7. The big question is, "How often will you need it in cold weather?"

And don't listen to the BoronBratwurst, every shop needs a fridge. :hmmm:
 
Having a shitter & sink would be nice but you need to add huge work & $$$ to run plumbing and to your septic. Then you MUST keep it heated 24 -7. The big question is, "How often will you need it in cold weather?"

I didn't think about plumbing cost or heating it, I'll be honest. Now that you mention the cold though, I'd rather poop in my garage than put on layers and mukluks, trudge through -20C weather and take it all off again to have my constitutional.. Especially after chili night. Maybe just keep a five gallon bucket in the corner.
 
I didn't think about plumbing cost or heating it, I'll be honest. Now that you mention the cold though, I'd rather poop in my garage than put on layers and mukluks, trudge through -20C weather and take it all off again to have my constitutional.. Especially after chili night. Maybe just keep a five gallon bucket in the corner.
It's times like those that I'm glad I spent some time working flat rate... learning to work while stifling back the urge to shit yourself or piss in your boots really paid off! ;)
 
Since my garage has the old oil furnace that came out of the house, I will tell you there is a lot of value in having a heating system that requires no thought or effort to keep at 55°F/13°C all day, every day. It keeps paint and chemicals from freezing, but more importantly it keeps the concrete slab at a bearable temperature. Those of you in colder climes know all too well: It can be 75°F in the shop, but if that slab is cold, your feet are cold. If your feet are cold, you're cold.

One thing I like about the oil-fired furnace is that I can (and do) dump in filtered, separated drain oil or hydraulic fluid to lengthen my run time. Yes, I have to be very careful that there's no coolant or particulate matter in there but it's not given me a problem straining oil through a paint filter. I can get a few gallons of diesel fuel, too, if I'm running short and the delivery truck won't be by for a few days. The downside is that it takes up what in my garage is a lot of real estate, since it's floor-standing. Oil-fired overheads are available, either specifically for waste oil or for standard heating oil.

You'll want to factor in the cost of a plumbed air system, too, especially with that size shop. Use 3/8"NPT fittings at the ends where the couplers will be installed and use matching-size 3/8"NPT couplers. It's all about airflow at the tool (more on that in a minute). A hose reel is nice on the hoist, but dragging the hose halfway across the shop from it can be a pain. Every inch of hose represents a pressure drop, and it's worse if there's a bend in it.

On the subject of air systems, and everyone reading this should consider this, plumb all your air fittings with the newer Milton "V"-style fittings (don't forget the one at the compressor if it's not hard-plumbed!). If you're currently using the standard ARO or Milton A, M, and T styles that virtually everyone uses, you will not believe the difference in air tool performance, particularly with rotating-shaft tools. Any and all of the popular, standardized air hose/tool fittings flow in the neighborhood or 25CFM. Even the giant industrial P- and G-style fittings that require a minumum half-inch air hose flow in the 50s. The Milton V-style fittings flow an incredible 74CFM while being "standard" sized... in fact, until you get the plugs changed on all your tools, you can plug ARO, A/M/T-style plugs into the Milton V-style couplers. There is no air-tool coupler on the market that can come within 15CFM of the design, even those big 1/2"NPT-only ones.

I came across those fittings when I plumbed my garage for air, and decided I'd try them. I did just the compressor, hose, and my 1/2" impact as a test. That was enough to convince me to swap out everything I own. The difference was remarkable; night-and-day when paired with a 3/8" ID hose (I used Flexzilla--nice because it's very light, but it's the size that's important). I still worked at the diesel shop then, and after demonstrating the difference the decision was made to upgrade the entire shop to the V fittings. They don't cost much more than regular fittings, and are actually cheaper when bought online. I got mine from JB Tool Sales; probably not an option for our Maple Leaf friends but, they were about half the price of buying regular couplers locally (even cheaper than my cost when I was at CarQuest!). Do the couplers when you do the system, and get plugs for the tools a few at a time if necessary to complete the upgrade. Your old fittings will most-likely work; worst case I had a very-slight hiss at the tool with my old M-style plugs prior to finishing the swap.

The downside is that your compressor will run more often since you're flowing 3 times the air. If you're using a crappy portable oilless compressor you will completely outrun it using a die grinder or DA. Of course, whichever tool you're using works that much more quickly. I can't recommend these fittings enough.
 
tell you my shop wish list should i EVER get the chance to do something from scratch

full floor water piped for HEAT..with the ability to "bypass" the heater and do a coiling in a freezer for summer cooling
pre wired for "overkill" amount of LED light..those of us doing body work HATE shadows but this also prevents eye fatigue
4post roller/stacker, 4 post LONG(4dr long box anyone?), scissor.....i dont think id bother with a 2post unless is was the super duty versions built for long wheelbase trucks
8-10ft spacing drops..AIR and power, the sole reason behind this is short air runs, short power runs, the chance of never needing an extension cord....i did this in my 20x20 and id never live without it
main exterior power/air/water drop at each door



now heres where i start breaking things up a bit...and killing the "norm" of things

cubical wall covering
i had a chance to clear out a MASSIVE office of them for free, and did it for teh scrap metal as these are the steel mesh steel post type NOT the wood ones.....i quickly found out that they are fire proof, have an insulated core in them and due to the design are sound proof/muffling.....you do the interior walls of a shop in these and you loose ALL echo, insulate the shop, and make it very VERY hard to burn down...i took a cutting torch to one of them....while i could get a little flame for a split second after melting, they refuse to light and stay lit, the "tin box" echo of pole barns is HELL on a good day, and even a standard shop with any flat wall is echoy.....cubical walls are about 3inches thick..but oh soo worth it, with ZERO other insulation in the dead of winter with several feet of snow on the ground, fire up the wood stove and you could get the shop "workable" in about 3 hours and hold it at that point(zero ceiling insulation either), dead of summer 95+ with silly humidity, it was like stepping into a refrigeration unit at about 60-65 degs which it would hold till around 6-7pm when the temps outside would start falling it was time to open her up

compressor room
shut that bitch up! so you can hear yourself think
my plan here would be to build a 5x5 or so room (depending on tools likely under the loft)with a MASSIVE intercooler/condensor unit and the biggest compressor you can find, sound proof the shit out of it, in adition you could go with a bigger room and add toilet and sink here as well as your furnace if its not a hanging unit

LOFT
this isnt for a man cave but if you have say a 15ft ceiling youll have space between the rafters that will typicly give you an aditional 2ft at the ends and go up to about 6 ft in the center..you basicly take the rear most wall to the first rafter which is useualy 10-15 feet and then the full width of the shop ceiling space and put your shitter up there, sink, fridge, and couch, the other half of this becomes "carefull" storage, or semi clean work area, for carbs and small engines, below you is your machine shop up, IE all your tool boxes, a couple old fridges as chemical cabinets(neer fire proof,moisture resistant, and hold a pretty solid 55-65 degs year round), drill press and any other "big" tools....the idea here is to MAXIMIZE space in the rest of the shop and kill the clutter, bonus if the loft can overlook everything for pics, ideas and jsut a view of your acomplishments....sometimes reflection is the best motivation


exterior doors.....
first off build a damn porch for your "man door", cause most "shop" kits just have a flat wall with a door...so every time its piss pouring raining your standing in the rain fumbling with your keys, secondly it would be nice when its raining and you need some air to be able to go out there and sit and catch your breath

toy doors
this is all dependent on shop layout but that said i would have a minimum of 2 doors, 1 thats a BIG bitch ie 20x10/20x12 or such..think "rv" as you may never have one, the next home buyer might and its a huge resale for a shop to be able to say "you can pull in your boat, RV or big rig", secondly a "car" size door typicly at the other end of the shop, something 10x10....now these can be your typical pole barn "slide" doors, tho they are a bitch to get "air tight" in any form and critter penetration is a nightmare!!!!!!fact is no matter what kind of door you put in think about critter entry thru the cracks, and once they get in they will keep getting in and ruin your shit

HEATING/cooling/ventilation
haveing a gas fired boiler baseboard system in the house from the 50s....ive learned some things....a warm floor is a gift!
id kill for water piped floor for heating and cooling, and in all honesty from what ive seen with out house, gas fed boiler hot water fed baseboards its rather inexpensive to run, zero maintenance, the system is from the 50's and has only needed a new flew door, and a transformer, my ideal twist to this would be to get a big freezer or something, plumb it up like a kegerator, but run a secondary valved line to your floor thru it for summer cooling

some form of overhead heat is a MUST for when you need it warmed up NOW...ive done the wood stove and unless your getting your wood for free and have someone to man it..its just not worth the hastle when your neck deep and the fires going out, you cant stop and it goes out, id KILL for docs waste furnace, then theres the fact an open flame that big is never a good idea, it takes FOREVER to get it up to working temps, woodstove heat is ONLY good in a shop for maintaining heat unless youve got 3-4 hours to burn waiting on it, then there is the cost and logistics of firewood, storing the firewood, splitting it and then the bugs and rodentia that come with it, i think if you do the math add in the time to get it, split it, stack it, store it the shed for it(you do NOT want it stored in your shop tho its nice to grab a pallet of split with a forklift) and then weigh all of that against gas, waste or other youll find its just easier to say no wood here unless your on alot of land with alot of tree fall which means free wood..even then time is money but youve gotta deal with the tree fall anyway

ventalation..i cant stress this one enuf, at each end of the shop, get yourself the BIG gable end flap type ends, and the fastest air moving fans you can, i used those BIG(size of a 55gal drum in dia) yellow fans made for hooking to ducting for drying out flood damage and such...noisy as hell but 1 will EVAC smoke, fumes etc from a 30x60 in about 2 mins, and fully clear it in 5

foundation
the foundation itself..oy the things you learn
for this one..do NOT just go with a flat slab like most do for a polebarn/shop..a flat slab leaves you with MASSIVE moisture problems, in adition any roof runoff splatters the ground and then goes between the base of the walls and the slab, dont even THINK about gutters, since the snow yeild will rip them off the shop, but even if you had gutters the rainfall on the ground will wick past the walls too
in fact you can get yourself some bonus height here and kill some small leg critter issues in a single blow if you do a 1-2foot rise foundation onto the main slab..your 12ft building just became 13-14ft ceiling etc you get the idea...but you can build you door into it, your garage doors into it thus killing critter entry, now if your on even the slightest slope DO NOT build up the ground on the low side, instead CARVE in the high side, go concreete and then save in building materials, anything extra could mean out buildings, wood shed, spare panels for repairs etc, my general rule on a shop would be a BARE MINIMUM of a 1foot from ground level rise of concreete with the outter skin of the building skirting OVER it and down by 3inches this will allow for the best insulation, critterproofing, moisture breaking, i cant imagine a down side to it

as for the concreete itself go OVERKILL and you can actualy save money, the trick is in the fiber strand reinfoced stuff...it means NO rebar, but also means that your slab doesnt need to be as thick for your needs meaning less concreete ..however id ALWAYS go thinker than you need, and if you want a 2 post lift put in some footings where you ant it..even if you never put one it..on a side note to the chop stand..i dropped a VERY heavy I beam from 15ft up trying to get it into a storage spot.....this bastard was heavy enuf to have a ramcharger struggling for traction while hoisting, something went wrong and it let go, i left a quarter size "chip" in the floor....shit be TOUGH...
also you do NOT want expansion joints but instead "zip strips" this will leave "tiny" cracks that act as expansion but will leave you with as smoothh of floor possible

lastly i would NOT run anything into the foundation if you can help it aside from your heated slab....think of it as preventitive maintinance, if your "utilitys" dont run under the slab. if anything happens to them youll never have to break the slab

POWER
code will dictate some things BUT if you can.....
you want your main box as close to the man door as humanly possible....fire or other electical issue, your escaping its right there on the way out!, and you want a MAIN KILL on said box that kills the entire shop in one swoop

a small shelf for whatever you may , a key hanger and such too, but sectioned lighting for the shop, a multitude of switches, interior lighting exterior lighting all of it right next to the door, i use the fuse box however for my compressor switch


ill leave this here for now and add to it as i remember it, but this is the "main" stuff....i do NOT recomend any windows and definatly refrain from any "clear" type panels that dont last many years, and the roof should have ZERO holes in it..go thru the walls or end eves instead...your in snow country!
 
Wow...more great advice, thank you for taking the time to type all the responses out! Lots to think about and consider.

I was looking at the costs involved with running an exterior wood fired boiler, and think that is a huge investment that would take a decade to recoupe the costs, may still run the piping for the heated floors if the costs are not to much. And the thoughts about wood, cutting, splitting storage....very relevant. I do have a ton of dead fall on the property, but that doesn't mean the wood is still "good"....will it burn, sure, but the fire will eat through it in no time, which means more time having to re-load. May still go with a wood burning stove in shop, with electric, or gas heat to keep things at a reasonable temperature.

Sink and shitter would be nice....but not necessary. Been a trucker for over 20 years now....I can hold it. ;) A small fridge is definitely a must.

Like the idea of a compressor room....and those V-style air fittings will be on the list. I have an oilless compressor, I call it the compressor of hate....man is that thing offensive when it's running! I also have a small old sears belt driven compressor....works pretty good. I usually hook the two into the main line and it works pretty good at keeping up with my air flow needs. But a reasonable priced "big" compressor would be much better....will keep my eyes open for one at the local auction houses, same for a lift.
 
Even if you don't hook it up right away, I would plumb in the in-floor heating for the future. Must be nice in BC to even think about electric heat. Here in Ontario you would struggle to give away a house with electric heat as our electricity is probably the highest in the country and will be going up for years to come thanks to that Biotch in Toronto that is running this province into the ground and taking all our money out of our pockets, our kids pockets and grandkids pockets for many years to come.
 

SiteLock

SiteLock
Back
Top